Attentive service food was good, something different. We would return. Potato salad and macaroni salad were complimentary. Polish comfort food.
Mary G., Toms River, NJ 7/9/16
Well I held-out and waited a week, plus I let my Mom (Irene A.) make her Testimonial 1st (Ladies First)!
So, now for us returning SILs for the 2nd time, it was not just a one-time strike of luck that this food is To-Die-For on the 1st time! This stuff is Consistently Delicious!
I tried more new items on their menu today and I am just Blown Away how this all these foods reminds me so much of my Great Grandma's, Grandma's and Aunt Mary's Fantastic Ukrainian Food that I grew up on in North Jersey and they were right from the Ukraine!
Tradition and Family and that's the way I feel when walk in to SILs ~ Like Family! Great Foods, Soups, Take-out, Deserts and Everything ~ FANTASTIC!
Polish and Ukrainian foods are so similar and was was just like being right then again in their kitchens, so thanks too for welcoming our Heritage as well!
Thank you Ginny the Owner, Matt Owner and Chef and Candy our Waitress for being so accommodating and warm and friendly too!
Your Family Atmosphere is one of SILs best assets, besides the Mouth Watering Home-Made Food!
See ya for a 3rd time and I hope many, many more to come visits to come real soon!
Jim B./Weebles, Forked River, NJ 12/13/2016
I went to Sil's Pierogi last week with my son, Jimmy B. and met Ginny and her son, Matt - Owner & Chef. They were so friendly and welcomed us to our first visit to their lovely restaurant. The atmosphere was so warm, just like my Polish relatives. The waitress, Candy was also so friendly and attentive.
Now to the delicious homemade selection... The Pierogi with sour cream, my favorite was just like I remembered - just like the ones that Great Grandma and Grandma used to make, excellent! We also loved the Haluski with Kielbasa.
The Grab & Go was great, we took home the potato pancakes with apple sauce, the potato and macaroni salads all delicious. Also, the cheese Babka, the Apple Cranberry Loaf (they have a large selection ) and of course the Chruscik (we shared) all so yummy!
I'm spreading the word to all my friends, who want to enjoy homemade comfort food and more, to go to Sil's for a delicious meal!
We're returning next week for their Stuffed Cabbage served with tomato sauce, more Pierogi, Chruscik and other goodies (which would make great Christmas Gifts) ... They also have Gift Certificates - perfect for Christmas Gifts! Thank you SILs!
Irene A., Brick, NJ 12/7/16
Great service you have to wait for your order to cook nothing is is pre cooked. For is great real down home cooking. They offer eat In or take out. I suggest you call ahead if you do not want you mouth to water while waiting. This is on my must eat at list.
Paul H., Toms River, NJ 9/20/16
Returned to Sils for the second time and placed an order for take-out. I can honestly say that this food is Rock Star! The lentil soup was so delicious and thick. My girlfriend and I are currently fighting over the last pierogi. Best service and extremely friendly staff! We'll be back soon. Five stars!
Joe L., Toms River, NJ 10/10/2016
I love Sil's pierogi! My mother and I walked in and it smelled delicious- like my Polish-American grandmother's kitchen! We ordered the Potato/Farmer's Cheese Pierogi and the Sauerkraut/Mushroom Pierogi- absolutely delicious! The staff was friendly and accommodating. The other food that came out of the kitchen looked wonderful as well! I highly recommend Sil's Pierogi!
Sharon P., Toms River, NJ 6/16/16
1071 Highway 37 West, Suite #5, Toms River NJ 08755 Tel 732-575-7218